Hot, not, hot, hot, not, not (leaving a pregnant girlfriend is a huge turn-off!), not.

Based only on physical appearance I would say absolutely NADA to Chad Michael Murray (shudder) and not really to Ryan Reynolds (although his bod looks pretty hot in this shot). We won't get into the "Nice or Not" side of the story...

hot
(really) hot
NOT!
hot
not
not
hot

hot
hot
not
hot
hot (but not as hot as james lafferty) ;)
not
HOT!

The first six are big nots, but James Marsden is all about HOT! Love.

OMG Dermot Mulroney... I just fell out of my chair. No one ever says him... but he is SO HOT. Also, Ryan Reynolds? YES.

ooohhh I'm drowning in a puddle of drool... chad... ryan...

Channing - Not
Wentworth - HOT
Ryan - HOT
Dermot - HOT
Chad - Not
Billy - Not
James - Not

I haven't read your answers yet, I know I'm behind... Here's mine:

Hot
VERY HOT
Warm
Hot
Warm
Not
Hot